Local Elevator Choices |
Cash Market
Locked in Price and Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Widely used and well understood |
lose flexibility |
| Can sell cash most any time |
Sales are irreversible |
| No cash involved other than Transportation |
Cash prices are tied to local conditions |
| Price is known immediately |
|
Used when you like the price and the basis |
|
| |
|
Forward Contract
Locked in Price and Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Lock in price for future delivery at a certain location |
You have locked yourself in and must deliver |
| Most widely used and understood forward Pricing tool |
Have no advantage to narrow basis |
| Simple and legally binding |
|
| Usually made in any amounts |
|
No margin calls |
|
Used when you like the price and the basis |
|
| |
|
Basis Fixing Contract
Not locked in Price but locked in Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Used when you like the basis but not the price |
Lose title to the crop upon delivery |
| Local elevator tool - you know who you are dealing with |
Could end up with the basis too wide |
| Can fix a favorable basis into the future |
Must deliver grain to the elevator holding the contract |
| |
|
Minimum Price Contract
Not locked in Price but locked in Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Like buying a call option |
You will not be able to take advantage of narrowing basis |
| No storage costs because you deliver crop in fall |
Should only be done in years with with narrow basis option premium is |
| Establish a floor price for crop with upside potential |
Option premium taken out of check could represent all your profit |
| Cash for grain is received when delivered in fall, Call premium taken out of harvest check |
|
| Most you can lose on crop is option premium paid |
|
| Local elevator tool - you know who you are dealing with, do not need brokerage account |
|
| |
|
Hedge to Arrive (HTA)
Locked in Price but not Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Does exactly the same thing as a hedge |
Was abused in the past |
| Local elevator tool - You don't need to know specifics of future tradings and can deal with local personnel |
Locked into a single outlet for your grain |
| Do not tie up money in a margin account |
Can't place as complex orders as with future contract |
| Used when you like the price but not the basis |
Do not roll between marketing years |
| Can roll within the marketing year to take advantage of narrowing basis |
|
| |
|
Futures Pricing
|
Hedging
Locked in Price but not Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Increases your market flexibility |
Requires margin money to maintain account |
| Extends your marketing season on both ends |
Need to sell a fixed amount of at least 1000 bu. With 5000 bu being more advantageous |
| Used with a wide basis, you hope to capture profit from narrowing basis |
Requires self disciple to avoid speculating in the futures |
| Used when you like the price but not the basis |
|
| Can be rolled into other contract months |
|
| |
|
Sell Cash—Buy Futures
Locked in Basis but not Price |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Take advantage of narrow basis at harvest |
Wide harvest basis at time of sale would work against you |
| Cost to Carry Futures usually considerably less than cost to carry crop in bin |
Danger of Speculating in Futures |
| Most of the value of the crop is available at the time of sale (Usually the fall) |
Must look at futures contract in same way as crop stored in bin |
| Done when you like the basis but not the price |
Must Maintain margin account and are subject to margin calls. |
| Eliminates storage at harvest |
|
| |
|
Buy Put Option
Locked in Price Floor but not Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Floor price is fixed with potential to take advantage of price rise |
Premium costs can be very high taking away profit potential |
| Flexibility, can roll the option up as prices rise |
Basis risk is still there |
| No margin money is required, risk limited to cost of premium |
Give up premium if market goes down |
| Can be looked at as price insurance |
Premium can be very high during volatile markets which usually occur when prices are high |
| Done when you can lock in favorable floor price but are not happy with the basis |
|
| |
|
Sell Futures--Buy Call Option
Locked in Price with insurance but not Basis |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Establish favorable price with insurance against break away market |
Give up some profit potential |
| Can be less expensive than a put option |
Basis risk is still there |
| Often called a synthetic Put |
More price risk than a straight Put Option |
Offers marketing flexibility |
|
Do if price is right but not the Basis and feel the market could go higher |
|
| |
|
Sell Cash—Buy Call Option
Locked in Basis and floor price with up side potential |
| Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Take advantage of narrow basis at harvest |
Wide harvest basis at time of sale would work against you |
| Cost of call option less than Cost to carry Crop in Bin |
Must look at Call Option in same way as crop stored in bin |
| Most of the value of the crop is available at the time of sale (Usually the fall) |
Premium costs can be very high taking away profit potential |
| Done when you like the basis but not the price |
|
| Eliminates storage at harvest |
|
| No margin money if required, limit the loss to the value of the option |
|